Op-Ed: Concerns grow over appointments to Institute of Statistics board
The Puerto Rico Science
Policy Action Network (PR-SPAN) and CienciaPR, the largest network of Puerto
Rican scientists in the world, is echoing the concerns expressed by the
American Statistical Association and the Association of Economists of Puerto
Rico about recent appointments to the Board of Directors of the Puerto Rico
Institute of Statistics and how these threaten the autonomy and integrity of
On January 7, Dr. Ron
Wasserstein, executive director of the American Statistical Association (ASA),
the largest and most prestigious statistical community in the world, sent a letter to Arnaldo Cruz, chairman of the Board of
Directors of the Puerto Rico Institute of Statistics, expressing serious
concerns about the recent appointments made by Gov. Ricardo Rosselló to the PRIS Board of Directors.
In the letter, Wasserstein
explained that ASA is deeply concerned because the appointments do not appear
to adhere to PRIS’ organic law and thus undermine the function and independence
On Nov. 28, 2018, Rosselló appointed economist Nicolás Muñoz, certified public
accountant Harry Santiago and Secretary of Economic Development and Commerce, Manuel
Laboy to the Board of Directors of PRIS. The appointments were made because the
terms of three of the seven members of the Board had expired.
Article 7 of the Puerto Rico Statistics Institute Act establishes that the
Board of Directors must be composed of seven members, six of them “persons
of recognized personal and professional integrity, objectivity and competence
in any of the fields of statistics, economics and planning” and one government
official to be appointed by the governor.
However, two of these three
appointments do not follow the law of the Institute of Statistics. In the first
place, the appointment of Laboy exceeds the limit of one government official,
since Alex López-Echegarray, current member of the Board, is an advisor to the
Senate of Puerto Rico and a member of the Board of the Conservatory of Music.
On the other hand, Santiago,
does not have an academic degree or credentials in the areas established by the
law to be a member of the Board of Directors.
The Puerto Rico
Science Policy Action Network (PR-SPAN) and Ciencia Puerto Rico echo the
concerns expressed by Wasserstein, the ASA, the Association of Economists of
Puerto Rico and other experts on the legality of recent appointments and how
they threaten the autonomy, integrity and independence of the Puerto Rico
Institute of Statistics.
We firmly believe that an
autonomous PRIS, free of political influence is necessary for Puerto Rico to
have reliable and high quality data and statistics, a road map to address the
multiple challenges facing the country, and coherent and evidence-based public
Therefore, we encourage the members of our communities to write to Cruz, and/or Rosselló, asking them to (1) consider the letters sent by the ASA and AEPR, (2) remove the members of the Board who do not meet the requirements of expertise, (3) remove one of the two government representatives from the Board, and (4) establish transparent, participatory and impartial processes to nominate future members of the PRIS Board and, if necessary, leaders within the staff of the Institute.